Pie plates are firm favorites of bakers, amateurs, and professionals alike, as additional kitchen bakeware that allows us to achieve delicious and perfectly baked goodies. They can come in different materials and various pretty designs, either in glass, metal, or ceramic. Hopefully, this article will be a great help for you to find the perfect pie plates. Here is a list of the seven best pie plates for baking that can help you achieve those perfect and yummy pies!
Comparison Chart
| IMAGE | PRODUCT | DETAILS | PRICE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Protector Shield | If you are looking for pie plates that are durable, easy to use, and prevent pies from burning and over-browning, then Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Protector Shield is the best choice for you! No more burnt pies and no more spillages. | ||
| Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate | If you are looking for durable and glass-made pie plates, then the Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate is the one for you! It is very safe to use in preheated ovens, microwaves, freezers, and dishwashers. It is great for pies, lasagnas, casseroles, and cakes. For me, this is one of the best pie plates for baking in this list. | ||
| Abbey Gift Amazing Woman Pie Plate | If you are looking for the perfect pie plate to give your baker friends that have pretty designs, then the Abbey Gift Amazing Woman Pie Plate is the perfect choice for you! It is one of the best pie plates for baking available in the market. | ||
| Anchor Hocking Oven Basics 6-Inch Mini Pie Plate | If you want evenly baked pies, then the Anchor Hocking Oven Basics Mini Pie Plate is something you may want to check on. It is well-designed, tough glassware that is a great addition to your kitchen! | ||
| Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate | If you are looking for pie plates perfectly and beautifully designed by an award-winning baker, then Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate is the best choice for you! They are perfect for homemade pies baked in golden perfection. These are the best pie plates for baking, in my opinion! | ||
| ZYER Pie Plate Easy Grab Glass Pie Pan with Handles | If you are looking for a pie plate that has the right size for a small family and small gatherings, then the ZYER Pie Plate Easy Grab Glass Pie Pan with Handles is the perfect choice for you. It is perfect for pumpkin pie, shepherds pie, and other pies. It will surely satisfy all your baking needs. | ||
| The Pioneer Woman Vintage Floral 9 Pie Plate | If you are looking for a pie plate that will be a beautiful finishing touch to your homemade pies, then The Pioneer Woman Pie Plate is the perfect one for you! Enjoy your pies with the beautiful floral designs of these pie plates. |
A Detailed Review on the 7 Best Pie Plates for Baking
Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Protector Shield
If you are looking for pie plates that are durable, easy to use, and prevent pies from burning and over-browning, then Mrs. Anderson’s Baking Pie Crust Protector Shield is the best choice for you! No more burnt pies and no more spillages.
Product Highlights
Mrs. Anderson’s Pie Crust Protector Shield allows you to fit 9.5-inch and 10-inch pies perfectly. It is made from strong and durable aluminum. This pie plate has pie crust protectors that can result in perfectly brown pie crusts. It is also dishwasher safe for easy cleanup.
The Good
This pie plate, as Mrs. Anderson’s promotes it, allows pies to rise, reduce spillage, and prevent the crusts from burning. It is easy to use and stays in place. You do not have to use aluminum foil to wad up your pies. As mentioned, it is dishwasher safe.
The Bad
The problem with this pie plate is that they usually do not fit properly, have the edges of your pies burned, and are flimsy and easily bent.
PROs
- Made of strong and durable aluminum
- Easy to use
- Easy to clean
- Dishwasher safe
CONs
- Does not fit properly
- Burns the edge of the pie
- Flimsy material
Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate
If you are looking for durable and glass-made pie plates, then the Pyrex Glass Bakeware Pie Plate is the one for you! It is very safe to use in preheated ovens, microwaves, freezers, and dishwashers. It is great for pies, lasagnas, casseroles, and cakes. For me, this is one of the best pie plates for baking in this list.
Product Highlights
The glass of this Pyrex Pie Plate has a non-porous surface, so it does not absorb food odors and flavors. It will not stain as well. Its design allows you to cook and serve straight from the oven to your dining table. It measures 9 inches in diameter, perfect for a single crust pie.
The Good
This pie plate is great because it is tempered glass, meaning it is difficult to break. As mentioned, it is odor and stain-resistant. It being glass, you can see the bottom and sides of the crust and saves you from guesswork if the pie is done. It is cheaper than the other pie plates on this list and in great quality.
The Bad
The downsides to this pie plate are that it is less resistant to thermal shock, meaning, if you suddenly place it in different temperatures, like from freezer to oven, it will crack. Some people may find their depth too shallow for baking pies. It is also difficult to clean.
PROs
- Made of tempered glass so difficult to break
- Odor resistant
- Stain-resistant material
- Saves you the guesswork if your pies are done
- Dishwasher safe
CONs
- Difficult to clean
- Less resistant to thermal shock
- Too shallow in depth
Abbey Gift Amazing Woman Pie Plate
If you are looking for the perfect pie plate to give your baker friends that have pretty designs, then the Abbey Gift Amazing Woman Pie Plate is the perfect choice for you! It is one of the best pie plates for baking available in the market.
Product Highlights
This pie plate measures 10.5 inches across and features a decorative scalloped edge, which can give your pies a pretty shape. It is ceramic and is oven and dishwasher safe.
The Good
As mentioned, the Abbey Gift Amazing Woman Pie Plate comes in pretty and beautiful designs. It is made of ceramic that can withstand high temperature and has great thermal shock, unlike the previous item listed. It is oven safe and dishwasher safe.
The Bad
The downside of this pie plate is that you still have to check constantly if the pie is already done. It easily breaks if suddenly transferred to a colder temperature fresh from the oven. It is also too shallow if you want pies with more fillings.
PROs
- Pretty design
- Great resistance to thermal shock
- Made of ceramic
- Oven and dishwasher safe
CONs
- You have to check if the pie is done constantly
- Easily breaks
- Too shallow in depth
Anchor Hocking Oven Basics 6-Inch Mini Pie Plate
If you want evenly baked pies, then the Anchor Hocking Oven Basics Mini Pie Plate is something you may want to check on. It is well-designed, tough glassware that is a great addition to your kitchen!
Product Highlights
The Anchor Hocking Mini Pie Plates measure 6 inches in diameter and 1.5 inches deep, which makes them perfect in baking small pies and desserts. Not only that, but it also has easy to grip handles. It is made of seamless and non-reactive and tempered glass, making it odor-resistant and prevents the mixing of flavors.
The Good
As mentioned, the Anchor Hocking Mini Pie Plate is made of tempered glass, making it durable and would last you for years. It has easy to grip handles, which makes serving quick and easy.
The Bad
The problems with this pie plate are that it is too fragile, too small for its size, and it is not dishwasher safe. It is prone to scratches if you place it in the dishwasher.
PROs
- Made of tempered glass
- Easy to grip handles
- Odor resistant
- Stain-resistant material
CONs
- Fragile glassware
- Too small size
- Not dishwasher safe
Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate
If you are looking for pie plates perfectly and beautifully designed by an award-winning baker, then Rose Levy Beranbaum’s Perfect Pie Plate is the best choice for you! They are perfect for homemade pies baked in golden perfection. These are the best pie plates for baking, in my opinion!
Product Highlights
The Perfect Pie Plates come with various colors and designs: there’s Blueberry (blue), Rose (red), Wheat (white), and Sage (green). A pie plate measures 9 inches in diameter, which is perfect for a single crust pie. It has a 4-cup capacity and is made from high-fired ceramic that has a scratch-free glaze that is decorative and durable. It is odor resistant and stain-resistant.
The Good
The Perfect Pie Plates are great because their deep-fluted edge allows you to make elaborately designed crusts for any pie. It is multifunctional, doubling as a baking dish for quiche or serving plate for veggies. As mentioned, it is odor resistant and stain-resistant.
The Bad
The problem with the Perfect Pie Plates is it is too shallow for other kinds of pie, and it is expensive.
PROs
- Comes in various designs and colors
- Made from high-fired ceramic
- 4-cup capacity pie plates
- Scratch-free design
- Odor resistant
- Stain-resistant material
CONs
- Too shallow for other kinds of pie
- Too Expensive
ZYER Pie Plate Easy Grab Glass Pie Pan with Handles
If you are looking for a pie plate that has the right size for a small family and small gatherings, then the ZYER Pie Plate Easy Grab Glass Pie Pan with Handles is the perfect choice for you. It is perfect for pumpkin pie, shepherds pie, and other pies. It will surely satisfy all your baking needs.
Product Highlights
The Easy Grab Glass Pie Pan with Handles measures 7-3/4 inch outer rim, 7-1/2 inch inner rim, 6-3/10 inch bottom, and 1-1/2 inch deep. It is just the right size. It is tempered glass that is oven safe and dishwasher safe. Its non-porous surface also makes it odor resistant and stain resistant, just like the previous items mentioned in this list. It is also easy to clean up.
The Good
The clear glass of this pie plate lets you monitor your baking. It has easy-grip petal-shaped handles for easier transfer. As mentioned, it is easy to clean up. It is odor resistant and stain-resistant as well.
The Bad
The downside to this product is it is too expensive for its size.
PROs
- Perfect sized pie plate
- Made of tempered glass
- Easy-grip handles
- Odor resistant
- Stain-resistant materal
CONs
- Some may find it too small
- Expensive price
The Pioneer Woman Vintage Floral 9 Pie Plate
If you are looking for a pie plate that will be a beautiful finishing touch to your homemade pies, then The Pioneer Woman Pie Plate is the perfect one for you! Enjoy your pies with the beautiful floral designs of these pie plates.
Product Highlights
The Pioneer Woman Vintage Floral Pie Plate measures 9 inches in diameter. It is oven safe and dishwasher safe. Plus, it has beautiful floral interior designs and comes in a red and white exterior motif.
The Good
What is great about this pie plate is that it is durable, beautifully designed, and sturdy.
The Bad
The problem with this pie plate is its edges that are too fragile. The exterior easily chips off as well.
PROs
- Durable material
- Beautifully designed
- Sturdy for the oven
- Oven safe
- Dishwasher safe
CONs
- Edges are fragile
- Exterior easily chips off
Conclusion
Now you know the best pie plates for baking! It is a very smart move to start investing in a pie plate. You will never know when you will need it for special occasions. Bear in mind that there are no perfect pie plates, and it all depends on what suits your baking and kitchen needs.
Remember, delicious pies also rely on the pie plates that can contain them, so carefully choose what you need. You can also try and make a Vegetarian casserole on it. Now, you have seven choices available to help you achieve those delicious and perfect brown pies! Know more about pie plates.